this post was submitted on
4 points (75% like it)
6 up votes 2 down votes
all 16 comments

[–]StupidQuestioner 6 points7 points ago

There are some studies that say exercise can be effective against depression.

Studies on St John's Wart indicates it might have some beneficial effect on depression.

[–]instapunish 0 points1 point ago

A study cofunded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) found that St. John's wort was no more effective than placebo in treating major depression of moderate severity.

[–]carac 0 points1 point ago

I don't know if you have seen this study in which Zoloft has performed a little worse :)

http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/287/14/1807.long

That being said:

  • exercise (especially outdoors in direct sun) is certainly effective and always a good thing to do in the right amount;

  • vitamin D seems to also work in many people in fighting winter depression.

[–]jsantos17 4 points5 points ago*

St John's Wort has shown beneficial effects. Just be cautious and tell any medical professional that you're taking it, since it has myriad of interactions.

EDIT: Seriously, don't use any other medication along with St. John's Wort before asking a medical professional.

[–]mrsapocalypse 4 points5 points ago

If you are a female, be aware that St. John's Wart can also lessen the effectiveness of birth control - just FYI.

[–]davehodg -1 points0 points ago

Have a bash at going wheat-free. Lots of anecdata, no actual studies. Many people are quietly intolerant and effect range from IBS to acne to depression. There's lots of support out there. Dump the bread and pasta, take up rice and spuds.

[–]xavier47 4 points5 points ago

man, that smacks of serious woo

seems you hear a lot about "going wheat-free", which is a red flag to me that it is hype or a flat out scam

[–]davehodg 0 points1 point ago

Try it :) Ever heard any negative side-effects?

[–]xavier47 1 point2 points ago

"It worked for me" claims usually aren't true "Regressive Fallacy"

[–]davehodg 1 point2 points ago

I said anecdata :)

[–]xavier47 2 points3 points ago

I know, it's skeptic, I can't help myself

[–]davehodg 0 points1 point ago

It's closely related to the paeleo diet many people rave about and of course, it's a life-saver for people with Crohn's and other out and out allergies. But the theory is that wheat is a recent addition to our diet and in the last 50 years we've completely messed with it. 4ft golden fields are replaced with 2ft unrecognisably modified varieties.

I didn't suffer from any obvious allergies, but still, stopped eating wheat and lost 8 pounds, have to remember to eat sometimes and don't suffer from the "afternoon blahs" any more. Also, I've not had that nagging black mood that sometimes descended. Two other friends have done it and one has lost a LOT of weight.

Anecdata. Which is why I just say give it a stab. It's also a relatively cheap option. Drop bread and pasta, add spuds and rice. (And read ingredients on processed food. Most soy sauce had wheat for example).

I think it falls within the OP's parameters of cheap.

And yes, one of the more strident advocate blogs screams woo.

[–]elburto 0 points1 point ago

it's a life-saver for people with Crohn's

Coeliac is the disease where wheat is harmful. Crohnies have all sorts of triggers.

[–]davehodg 0 points1 point ago

Ooops. Sorry for keeping you awake. http://xkcd.com/386/

[–]EmpRupus 1 point2 points ago

It entire depends on the cause of depression. Depression is in many cases caused by chemical imbalance. If this is the case, then you have to see a doctor.

If it is instead caused by some incident or perspective in your life, you can go to motivational speakers.

Additionally, practice meditation, exercise, socialization etc.

[–]blueleo 0 points1 point ago

I've had problems with severe bipolar for over 40 years (diagnosed) and maybe even longer. Prescription meds help somewhat, I don't like talking to doctors, so I stay away from psychotherapy as much as I can, but put up with it enough to get my meds. I've done a lot of research, and I am not aware of anything that works (medicinally) that does not require a prescription. My sympathies go out to you, it can be very rough.